- Please note our option symbols beside each menu item for gluten free, dairy free, and vegan options.
- Please ask your server about dietary options or restrictions. MM=Mini Meal.
- All items plus applicable taxes.
- The Old Newcastle House uses trans-fat-free oil.
- Some items may contain or have in contact with nuts or seafood. Please ask your server.
Starters
Garlic Shrimp | 16.75
Dine In Only – Baked shrimp marinated in white wine & garlic topped with cheddar & mozzarella. Served with garlic toast
Bruschetta | 16.75
Fresh tomato, basil, red onion, roasted garlic on warm flatbread. Topped with parmesan cheese, roasted garlic aioli & balsamic glaze
Add mozzarella, cheddar or feta cheese | 3.45
Spin Art Dip | 15.95
Dine-In Only – Baby spinach, artichoke hearts, asiago & cream cheese topped with cheddar & mozzarella cheeses. Served with soft pita & nacho chips
Nachos | 19.95
Dine In Only – White tortilla chips, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, shredded lettuce, green onions, tomatoes & peppers. Served with salsa & sour cream. Add grilled chicken or seasoned ground beef | 3.85
Panko Crusted Brie | 18.55
House made & fried, served with sweet chili dip
House Social Platter | 33.55
Dine In Only – Nachos & cheese, fries, chicken wings, garlic bread, fried mozzarella sticks, onion rings. Salsa, sour cream & ranch on side
Chicken Quesadilla | 18.55
Flour tortilla, seasoned chicken, fresh salsa, cheddar cheese & mozzarella. Served with sour cream on the side
Garlic Bread | 8.15
Roasted garlic & house herb butter on toasted ciabatta bread
Add mozza, cheddar or feta cheese | 3.60
Add jalapeños | 1.75 Add bacon | 2.90
Chicken Wings – 10 Pieces | 18.99
Ask your server for our wide variety of sauces & rubs available for your wings. Additional sauces or spices, $1 each.
Choose from over 25 different styles…get creative, mix two different flavours together! Try Tequila Lime & Cajun or Chipotle Mango
Naked, BBQ, Mild, Medium, Hot, Suicide
Honey Garlic, Pineapple Curry, Sweet Chili Thai, Smoked Lime & Tequila, Orange Ginger, Garlic Parmesan, Teriyaki, Guinness BBQ
Caribbean Jerk, ‘Swanny Style’ (Hot & Butter), Caesar Drizzle, Curry, Dry Seasoning Salt, Dry Cajun, Dry Lemon Pepper
Dry Chipotle Mango, Dry Sea Salt & Cracked Pepper, Dry Curry, Dry Maple Bacon, Dry Tex Mix, Dry Mango Habanero, Dry Sriracha
Cheese Sticks | 13.95
The best cheese sticks in town. Served with ranch or marinara
Deep Fried Pickles | 12.65
House made panko crusted dill pickle spears served with ranch or garlic aioli
Soup & Salad
Add fire roasted shrimp or grilled chicken to your salad | 5.25 ea
Soup Du Jour | 5.75
Made fresh daily. Ask your server what’s cookin’
French Onion | 8.95
Dine In Only – Classic french onion soup covered in swiss & mozzarella. Served with garlic crostinis
Garden Salad
Starter 6.30 | Entrée 11.55
Mixed greens with seasonal veggies with your choice of dressing
Spinach Salad
Starter 9.10 | Entree 15.35
Fresh spinach, dried cranberries, roasted sunflower seeds, roasted red pepper, feta cheese, bacon bits, drizzled with poppyseed dressing and topped with fried onion strings
Carol’s Cheeseburger Salad
Starter 12.75 | Entrée 18.50
Mixed greens, bacon, cheddar cheese, red onion, pickle, cherry tomato, cucumber & our famous sliced burger served with ranch dressing
Greek Salad
Starter 8.10 | Entrée 14.30
Crisp romaine, black olives, red onion, cucumber, cherry tomatoes, feta cheese, tossed in Greek vinaigrette
Caesar Salad
Starter 8.10 | Entrée 14.30
Crisp romaine, bacon bits, parmesan cheese & croutons tossed in Caesar dressing
Poutinerie
Classic | 9.25
Baked Potato | 12.75
French fries, mozzarella & cheddar cheeses, bacon, brown gravy, green onions, sour cream drizzle
Bacon Cheeseburger | 12.70
French fries, mozzarella & cheddar, brown gravy, our famous hamburger, bacon, red onion, tomato, pickle
Sweet Goat | 11.55
Sweet potato fries with crumbled Ontario goat cheese & brown gravy
Curry | 9.25
French fries, mozzarella cheese, house curry sauce
Butter Chicken | 12.75
Tender marinated chicken breast tossed in house butter chicken sauce served over french fries & mozzarella cheese. Topped with green onions.
Burgers & Sandwiches
Served with Fries, Soup or Garden Salad.
We use fresh, never frozen Ontario chicken and beef!
We’ve been told we have the best homemade burgers in town… Try one and let us know!
Our burgers are now Gluten Free!
Not keen on a lot of bread? Have your sandwich wrapped up instead!
The ONH Club | 16.75
Grilled chicken breast, avocado aioli, applewood smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, tomato & mixed greens on a ciabatta bun
Buffalo Chicken | 17.30
Crispy chicken strips tossed in your choice of wing sauce, topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce & ranch dressing
Beef Dip | 18.55
Tender & shaved roast beef on a warmed ciabatta bun. Served with savoury au jus
Steak Sandwich | 20.95
Char grilled AAA center cut striploin, grilled to your liking, topped with sauteed mushrooms & beer braised onions. Served on a warm ciabatta bun
Grilled Veggie Wrap | 16.75
Seasonal grilled veggies, warm rice, goat cheese crumble & chipotle mango aioli
Butter Chicken Wrap | 18.55
Tender grilled chicken tossed in our house butter chicken sauce, fresh tomato, cucumber, red onion & crumbled goat cheese
Angry Chicken Sandwich | 18.55
Crispy or grilled chicken in a spicy BBQ sauce, applewood smoked bacon, cheddar cheese & jalapeño & onion straws
The Other Woman Burger | 19.65
6 oz homemade patty topped with the ONH secret sauce, smoked cheddar & mozzarella, applewood smoked bacon, sautéed mushrooms & crispy onion rings
Black Bean & Quinoa Burger | 14.99
Handmade black bean & quinoa patty, topped with chipotle mango aioli, tomato, red onion, pea shoots & fresh greens
Tap & Grill Burger | 13.90
Our 6 oz. homemade burger patty topped with all the fixings!
Mushroom Onion & Swiss Burger | 16.75
Sauteed mushrooms, beer-braised onions, Swiss cheese, fresh greens, piled high on our homemade burger patty. With garlic aiioli for extra flavour.
Messy Massey | 20.95
6 oz handmade patty topped with beer-braised onions, Ontario brie cheese, applewood smoked bacon, BBQ sauce, house coleslaw & onion rings
Add Ons
- Gluten free bun | 2.90
- Applewood smoked bacon or beer-braised onions or cheddar or Swiss | 1.75
- Smoked cheddar, or smoked mozzarella or brie | 2.60
- Jalapeños or hot sauce | 1.75 ea
- Extra patty | 3.85
Upgrade your Side
- Greek or Garden salad | 2.35
- Onion Rings | 2.15
- Poutine | 3.65
- Sweet Fries | 3.15
House Favourites
Veggie Stir Fry
MM 9.80 | Entrée 18.55
Crisp seasonal vegetables stir-fried & served over wild rice blend with your choice of sweet chili Thai, orange ginger, honey garlic, teriyaki or pineapple curry
Add fire roasted chicken or shrimp | 4.99
Chicken Fingers
MM 10.95 | Entrée 16.25
Crispy chicken fingers fried golden brown and served with house fries & plum sauce
Shepherd’s Pie
MM 10.45| Entrée 18.55
Lean ground beef with seasonal mixed vegetables topped with rich gravy, garlic mashed potatoes & cheddar cheese. Served with roll & butter on the side
Grilled Liver & Onions
MM 13 .65| Entrée 20.95
Grilled baby beef liver topped with beer braised onions & beef gravy. Served with garlic mash & seasonal vegetables. Served with roll & butter on the side
Gourmet Mac & Cheese
MM 9.30 | Entrée 13.90
Homestyle macaroni tossed in our creamy 3-cheese sauce topped with a buttery, golden brown panko breadcrumb crust
- Add applewood smoked bacon | 1.65
- Add grilled vegetables | 3.85
- Add chorizo sausage | 4.40
Fish & Chips
1 PCE 11.99 | 2 PCE 16.80
Lightly beer-battered fish served with house fries, coleslaw & tartar sauce
House Signatures
Bacon-Wrapped Cheese-Stuffed Meatloaf | 21.99
Lean seasoned ground beef wrapped in bacon, stuffed with smoked mozzarella cheese, smothered in a rich mushroom-red wine gravy, served with seasonal vegetables and your choice of a side
ONH New Yorker | 32.55
10 oz AAA centre-cut New York grilled to your liking & topped with savoury blue cheese compound butter, served with seasonal vegetables and your choice of a side
Add sautéed mushrooms or onions | 2.65
Grilled Atlantic Salmon | 20.95
Grilled Atlantic salmon topped with roasted garlic & lemon compound butter. Served with seasonal vegetables and your choice of a side
King Ave. Curry | 18.55
Seasonal vegetables simmered in a mild curry cream sauce, served with basmati rice or french fries with warmed naan bread. Add fire-roasted chicken or shrimp | 4.99
Yorkie Bowl | 22.50
Slow roasted beef smothered in our mushroom-red wine gravy -OR- Tender marinated chicken breast topped with our house butter chicken sauce. Served with garlic mashed potatoes & seasonal vegetables in a Yorkshire pudding bowl
Tuscan Penne | 22.50
Fire roasted chicken, red onion, black olives, peppers, cherry tomatoes & mushrooms tossed in olive oil & pesto. Topped with Ontario goat cheese & served with garlic toast
Substitute Chorizo sausage for $1.99
Panko Crusted Cajun Chicken Alfredo | 21.99
Sautéed mushrooms & onions tossed with bowtie pasta in our cajun cream sauce, topped with our crispy panko-crusted chicken breast. Served with garlic toast
Butter Chicken | 20.85
Tender marinated chicken in our robust house butter chicken sauce, served over basmati rice or french fries with warmed naan bread
Chicken Parmesan | 21.99
Hand-breaded or fire-grilled chicken breast topped with zesty marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese. Served with a side of linguine with marinara and garlic toast
Choose Your Side
Fries | Wild Rice | Garlic Mashed Potatoes | Soup
Salad (Garden, Caesar or Greek) | Seasonal Vegetables
Sides & Add Ons
House Fries SM | 4.75 Lg | 6.95
Sweet Fries Sm | 6.30 Lg | 9.45
Served with one of our house made garlic or chipotle aiolis
Onion Rings | 5.50
Fire Roasted Chicken | 5.25
Fire Roasted Garlic Shrimp Skewer | 5.25
Gravy | 2.45
Curry Sauce | 2.45
Extra Sauces, Dressings & Dips | 1.70 ea
Please talk to your server about dietary options or restrictions.
All items plus applicable taxes. The Old Newcastle House uses trans-fat-free oil.
Some items may contain or have come in contact with nuts and/or seafood. Please ask your server.
Desserts
Chocolate Molten Lava Cake | 6.30
Chocolate lovers unite! A Warmed lava cake oozing with rich chocolate fondant. This cake is the perfect end to your fantastic meal! Have it served a la mode for a truly delicious experience
Homemade Carrot Cake | 6.30
The best homemade carrot cake..period. Delectable moist carrot cake topped with our mouthwatering cream cheese icing & caramel drizzle
New York Style Cheesecake | 6.30
Creamy cheesecake filling served on a graham cracker crust. Topped with your choice of blueberry, cherry, chocolate or caramel topping.
Raspberry Greek Yogurt Cheesecake | 6.30
The perfect blend of Greek yogurt cheesecake and real raspberry puree, swirled together with moist chunks of perfect raspberry cake.
Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cheesecake | 6.30
A flourless extreme brownie base loaded with the dynamic duo of chocolate and peanut butter cheesecakes, all blended and topped with roasted almonds, chunks of brownie bites and a drizzle of dark chocolate!
Add a side, Ice Cream | 1.70 (Dine in Only)
Kid's Menu
All items are $7.99, served with pop or milk & ice cream for dessert
Chicken fingers & fries or veggie sticks
Fish & chips or veggie sticks
Pizza Pocket & fries or veggie sticks
Pasta with your choice of linguine or penne tossed in butter, marinara or alfredo sauce
Substitute sweet potato fries or onion rings for $1.50
Beer & Wine
Beer Menu
Draft Beer
10oz
20oz
60oz / Pitcher
Budweiser
4.55
6.15
18.25
Bud Light
4.55
6.15
18.25
Premium
10oz
20oz
60oz / Pitcher
Alexander Keith’s IPA
5.20
7.15
21.20
Michelob Ultra
5.20
7.15
21.20
Mill St. Tankhouse Ale
5.20
7.15
21.20
Mill St. Organic Lager
5.20
7.15
21.20
Import
10oz
20oz
60oz / Pitcher
Stella Artois
5.45
7.50
21.75
Guinness
5.45
7.50
Rolling Rock
5.70
7.90
23.50
Shock Top Belgian White
5.70
7.90
23.50
Black & Tan (1/2 Bud or Bud Light, 1/2 Guinness)
8.25
Limited Availability, May 2023, Newcastle Brown Ale, 7.70
Craft Beer
NEW: Naturally Light Beer, exclusive to The Old Newcastle House.
Per can | 4.80
Case of 4 | 18.45
Chronicle Brewery Rotating Crafts, ask your server | 7.10
Other Craft Beers
473ml Can | 7.80
Bobcaygeon Brewery
- Common Loon
- Dockside Red Ale
- American Pale Ale
- Strawberry Kiwi Sour
Burnt River Saw Cut
Old Flame
- Red
- Hazy Blonde
Flying Monkeys
- Juicy Ass IPA
- Freakshow IPA
Lakeshore Cider
Mill Street
- Juice Cloud
- Brickworks 501 Cider
- Stadium Peach Cider
Goose Island IPA
Rotating Chronicle – Ales from the Crypt, Lando, Chimera, ask your server.
Lightcaster Brewery
- Goldie “Kolsh”
- All Good IPA
Tallboys
Budweiser | 5.70
Bud Light | 5.70
Newcastle Brown Ale | 7.70
Michelob Ultra | 7.10
Bottle
Budweiser | 5.05
Bud Light | 5.05
Labatt Blue | 5.05
Molson Canadian | 5.05
Bud Light Lime | 6.15
Corona | 6.70
Coolers
Smirnoff Ice | 6.75
Bay Grapefruit | 6.75
Nutrl | 7.60
White Claw Raspberry | 7.60
Bud Light Strawberry | 7.60
MIKES Hard Ice Tea, Hard Peach Fuzz, Hard Sour Watermelon | 7.60
Wine Menu
House
6oz
9oz
1/2 Litre
Bottle
Jackson Triggs Merlot (House Red)
7.15
9.35
17.60
27.50
Jackson Triggs Sauvignon Blanc (House White)
7.15
9.35
17.60
27.50
White
6oz
9oz
1/2 Litre
Bottle
Folonari Pinot Grigio
8.95
12.45
23.25
30.25
Yellow Tail Chardonnay
8.95
12.45
23.25
30.25
Inniskillen Riesling
8.95
12.45
23.25
30.25
Blush
6oz
9oz
1/2 Litre
Bottle
Folonari Pink Pinot
8.95
12.45
23.25
30.25
Red
6oz
9oz
1/2 Litre
Bottle
Yellow Tail Cabernet Sauvignon
8.95
12.45
23.25
30.25
Folonari Valpolicella
9.15
12.75
23.75
30.60
Trapiche Malbec
9.15
12.75
23.75
30.60
Menage A Trois
10.45
14.60
25.55
36.85
Martini Bar
French Martini – 1.5oz | 7.80
A house favourite at the ONH! Shake it up over ice. Smirnoff Vodka, Raspberry Chambord & pineapple juice.
Hurricane – 1.5oz | 7.80
Get a taste of the 1940’s with our classic Hurricane. Orange juice, Captain Morgan’s light rum & Captain Morgan’s dark rum
Dirty Gin Martini – 1.5oz | 7.80
How dirty do you like it? Gordons Gin, dry Vermouth & olive juice shaken or stirred?
Speciality Coffees (1.5oz | 8.30 Each)
Monte Cristo
Grande Mamier & Kahlua, fresh coffee topped with whipped cream
B52
Grande Mamier, Kahlua & Baileys, fresh coffee topped with whipped cream.
Spanish Coffee
Brandy & Kahlua, fresh coffee topped with whipped cream
Irish Coffee
Jameson’s & Baileys, fresh coffee topped with whipped cream
Brandy Alexander
Brandy & Creme de Cacao, fresh coffee topped with whipped cream
Try a slice of our homemade carrot cake to compliment any Speciality Coffee
Cocktails
Classic ONH Caesar – 1oz | 7.70
Spicy or Dirty? You let us know!
Mott’s Clamato, Smirnoff Vodka, rimmed with Matt & Steve’s Caesar rim & a hint of olive juice. Topped with olives, an asparagus spear & a lime wedge
Margarita On The Rocks – 1.5oz | 8.30
Shake it up with our traditional Lime Margarita! Jose Cuervo Gold Tequila & Triple Sec, lime juice & a salt rim. Sweeten it up! Try our Strawberry Margarita!
Old Fashion – 1.5oz | 10.65
Ready to sit back and relax… Enjoy our famous old fashioned made with Bulleit Bourbon, orange bitters, sweetened with raw sugar, orange slices & maraschino cherries.
